Racket drop and the waiter's tray serve (why we can only say 'possible')
After the trophy position the racket head should drop behind your back with the elbow pointing up, then whip up to the ball. When it doesn't drop, the serve looks like carrying a waiter's tray and loses its acceleration path. Improve My Serve does not track the racket, so a shallow drop is only ever flagged as 'possible'.
From one phone video we measure trophy-position knee bend, contact height, arm extension and rhythm.
What is the waiter's tray serve?
The waiter's tray is a serve where the racket face opens to the sky behind the head, like holding a tray, instead of dropping edge-first behind the back. The result is a pushed, slow serve.
- It usually comes with a forehand-style grip, which makes the edge-first swing awkward.
- The racket head stays high instead of dropping, so it has a short path to accelerate.
- Contact often happens with an open face, so serves float or spin sideways.
What does a good racket drop look like?
- After the trophy position the racket head drops behind your back with the elbow pointing up.
- The drop is part of one motion: the legs push up while the racket falls, then the arm throws the racket up.
- Coaches often compare it to an overhand throw: elbow leads, hand whips last.
Why can the analysis only say 'possible'?
The racket is not tracked. The analysis reads a wrist–elbow proxy from your skeleton, so a shallow racket drop is shown as a 'possible' flag, never as a definite fault.
- Racket-face angle is not measured, so the 'tray' itself (the open face) cannot be seen directly.
- Grip is not measured either; check it with a coach or a close-up photo of your hand on the handle.
- Treat a 'possible' flag as a prompt to watch the racket-low-point frame yourself.
How do I fix a waiter's tray serve?
- Cue: let the racket head drop behind your back, then throw it up.
- Drill — Overhead throws: throw a ball over the net with an overhand throwing motion, elbow leads, hand whips last. 2 sets × 10.
- Check your grip: coaches recommend the continental grip for the serve; a forehand grip makes the tray almost automatic.
- Edge-to-ball: from the service line, swing up edge-first so the racket meets the ball late in the upward path.
How do I check my racket drop on video?
- Film from the side so the arm behind your back is visible, landscape, with the racket above your head in frame.
- Upload the clip: the report shows a racket-low-point key frame and a 'possible' flag if the wrist–elbow proxy looks shallow.
- Free on the web with no account: a few free analyses per day.
What a single phone video can and can’t measure
The honest scope of 2D pose analysis from one camera.
| What | From one phone video |
|---|---|
| Joint angles in the camera plane: elbow, knee bend, trunk tilt | Measured |
| Contact point relative to the front hip (side-on view) | Measured |
| Order and timing of hip, shoulder and arm movement | Measured |
| Serve trophy position, arm extension and contact height | Measured |
| Shoulder turn and hip–shoulder separation (3D rotation) | Estimate only |
| Racket drop: inferred from the wrist path, flagged as “possible” | Estimate only |
| Wrist and forearm rotation (pronation) | Not measured |
| Ball speed, spin and placement | Not measured |
| Grip and racket-face angle | Not measured |
Frequently asked questions
- Can video analysis detect a waiter's tray serve?
- Only indirectly. The racket face is not tracked, so the analysis flags a shallow racket drop as 'possible' from your wrist and elbow positions.
- Is the waiter's tray caused by grip?
- Often. A forehand-style grip makes the open-face tray position feel natural. Switching to a continental grip is the usual first fix.
- Is racket drop the same as the trophy position?
- No. The trophy position comes first; the racket drop follows it as the legs push up and the racket falls behind your back.
Try it on your own swing
Upload a 10–30 second clip and get your priorities in about a minute.
Check my serve for thisSources
The reference values on this page come from these studies. Thresholds are coaching guides, not calibrated limits.
- Jacquier-Bret et al. Kinematics characteristics of key point of interest during tennis serve among tennis players: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 2024. — Racket-low-point / external rotation ~130 deg; measured by wrist-elbow proxy only